WAPAT 2023 Abstracts


Area 1 - Methodologies and Technologies

Nr: 9
Title:

Data Analytics for Defence Workforce Simulation

Authors:

Katie Mortimer

Abstract: Simulation plays a key role in the workforce analysis and planning capability of the Australian Defence Force (ADF). This is done using Athena, an advanced workforce simulation tool suite, specifically developed to provide the ADF with a capability that can accurately model and simulate the complexity of the Defence workforce, with its hierarchical nature and highly interconnected structure. Athena Lite, a Discrete Event Simulation engine that simulates the progression of personnel through their careers, including postings, promotions and loss of personnel through attrition, while respecting workforce-specific prerequisites and conditions, is a part of this capability. It is a web-based, scalable decision support tool currently in use by ADF workforce planners. Athena Lite gives ADF users the ability to forecast their workforce, run ‘what-if’ scenarios, and find optimal recruitment and promotion policies to meet demand. However, in Defence workforces there is a high level of uncertainty – unexpected attrition, recruitment, and workforce unavailability, as well as new platforms and capabilities, are just some examples of this. With this high level of uncertainty, forecasting individual scenarios, or manually running multiple ‘what-if’ scenarios becomes time-consuming and places a high demand on the analyst to determine the ‘cause-and-effect’ of input changes on the large number of outputs. To meet this challenge, IRIS was created, a web-based data analytics toolbox designed to interface directly with Athena Lite. IRIS is based on a previous prototype outlined in (Mortimer, et al., 2021). It has two main goals: to sample a large input space and run Athena Lite many times with this input space, and to use data analytics to explore the created dataset. It automatically explores the health of a workforce, provides insights into the sensitivity of various parameters and outputs, and examines the nth order interdependencies and effects of inputs on outputs, as well as outputs on other outputs. To do this, users build their model in Athena Lite and enter input parameter ranges in the IRIS interface, before running the simulator up to 2000 times, in each run sampling the input parameters from between the user-input ranges. Three visualisations are then created to allow users to explore the dataset. In an interactive time-series plot, the user is able to explore the performance of units or ranks and find points that were particularly vulnerable. A correlation heatmap, created using Spearman’s correlation coefficient, displays the dependencies between simulation inputs and outputs, and an interactive Bayesian network gives users the ability to explore the effect of the dependencies. The user can explore the interactive network through mouse hovers and clicks, and make queries to see the direct effect of the relationships between parameters. IRIS is currently being used by ADF workforce planners. However, IRIS development continues, to increase the available analysis techniques and visualisations, with inclusion of techniques such as decision trees and principal component analysis. A planned future feature of IRIS involves further automation of the analysis, using natural language generation to create reports that provide plain English explanations summarising and highlighting key results. Mortimer, K., Nguyen, V., Caelli, T. & Hill, B., 2021. Simulation and Data Analytics for a Defence Workforce Transition. Sydney, NSW, MSSANZ, pp. 92-98.

Area 2 - Workforce Analytics - Practical Application and Theory

Full Papers
Paper Nr: 6
Title:

Defence Workforce Transition Simulation and Analysis

Authors:

Katie Mortimer, Cameron Pike and Vivian Nguyen

Abstract: Simulation plays a key role in the workforce planning of defence workforces, with their strictly hierachical nature, and complex interactions and interdependencies. In this paper, the Athena tool suite, containing Athena Lite and Athena Pro, is introduced. The Athena tool suite is the official workforce planning tool of the Australian Defence Force (ADF), and uses Discrete Event Simulation and hybrid Agent-Based Discrete Event Simulation to simulate the highly complex ADF workforce. These are web-based, scalable tools that have been specifically designed to be used by Defence workforce planners. Their use in the analysis of the Australian Army Aviation’s planned transition from the Tiger Armed Reconnaissance Helicopter to the Apache helicopter demonstrates their capability in identifying workforce shortfalls and risks, bottlenecks, and potential solutions through optimisation.
Download

Paper Nr: 7
Title:

Quantifying the Impact of Secondary Duties on Sailor Workload Through Simulation

Authors:

Victor Isaac

Abstract: Designing crewing concepts for ships requires complete information regarding the tasks that sailors must perform, since an incomplete understanding could result in unreasonable crew workloads and fatigue. It is therefore important to look at all sources of sailor workload. Primary duties, which belong to a billeted position, have been studied extensively in the past and are well-represented in existing crew models. Secondary duties, which are tasks assigned to individual sailors in addition to their primary duties, are not as well understood. This creates a significant risk in crew design. In this study, a simulation model has been developed to quantify the impact of secondary duties on sailor workload. The stochastic nature of the model makes it suitable for use in Monte Carlo experiments and allows it to explore the impact of combining one or more secondary duties with a sailor’s primary duties. This allows it to be used to create statistics suitable for applications, such as predicting fatigue rates, where extreme values are important. This paper describes the development, verification, and implementation of the model.
Download

Paper Nr: 8
Title:

Course Scheduling Under Uncertainty for Defence Workforce Training

Authors:

Trudy Lam, Vicky Mak-Hau and Kristan Pash

Abstract: In this paper, we revisit a previously studied Defence course scheduling problem where trainees are allocated to course sessions, the Simultaneous Sequencing and Allocation Problem. The courses have a non-linear prerequisite structure, each course has a number of sessions, and each session has a class size limit. The uncertainty in the planning is due to a historical pass-rate associated with each course, and a trainee will not be able to proceed once s/he fails a course. We develop a simulation-based three-stage solution algorithm that optimises the scheduling for each scenario using integer programming. The way pass-rates are handled is different from previous approaches, and because of this, we are able to provide decision-makers with better insights on best-case, average-case, and worst-case outcomes.
Download

Short Papers
Paper Nr: 5
Title:

Personnel Data Management System for Workforce Analytics

Authors:

Marcin Pilat

Abstract: An effective analytics solution relies on the right data and the right data management system. We present a data management system for personnel data that is specifically designed to enable efficient workforce analytics. The system is designed using dimensional modelling and implemented as a collection of star schemas over the business functions of workforce planning, recruitment, and retention. Special internal processing during the Extract, Transform, Load process streamlines the generation of the internal data tables.
Download